Note: This list speaks for itself, it is simply my 20 favorite songs of all time that include lyrics. For this list I have included extended commentary on each song. When I first published this list it was 110 songs long, and I will publish a full 250 this time in 5 installments. With the first publication, several people let me know that they had discovered new songs from it, and honestly that is the best outcomes I could hope for. This list does not include ambient music or jazz, two genres I also love. This list is a product of nearly 40 years of intensive music listening, so it is, at a minimum, highly curated. Thank you for reading, and may you find a new favorite somewhere on this list.
1. Cape Canaveral — Conor Oberst
For the first time since I began making versions of this list, I have a new number one. Conor Obrest’s Cape Canaveral has slowly, almost imperceptibly, worked its way past every other song I love. I didn’t exactly wake up one morning and decide that it was the greatest song ever. I simply noticed that I had already begun treating it that way. I return to it constantly, and it still gives me full-body chills and moves me to tears almost every time I hear it. After nearly forty years of obsessive music listening, Cape is as good of a number that I can come up with.
Conor is my number five artist of all time, and the fact that Cape Canaveral has become the song above all others that explains why. Number one. There it is. Man oh man. I didn’t see this one coming.
I have loved Cope for about eight years since I first heard it shorty after the release of the record it is on, Conor’s solo self titled debut from 2008. It is in my opinion his most beautiful and moving song. Conor also wrote my number 13 favorite song, Easy/Lucky/Free, which I write about below. Cape Canaveral uses the space program—those televised launches from decades ago, the spectacle of rockets lifting off into the unknown—as a proxy for growing up in America in the latter part of the 20th century. It’s about distance, aspiration, and the strange way in which memory reshapes people and moments over time.
It is one of the most gorgeous American songs ever written. “I watched your face age backwards / changing shape in my memory / you told me victory’s sweet / even deep in the cheap seats.” This is one of the loveliest passages ever set to music. Oberst is doing something subtle and devastating here—he’s taking the language of triumph and reframing it from the margins. Victory’s sweet even deep in the cheap seats is not a grand statement, however it is oddly triumphant. It’s about making meaning over time, with partial access, and moving from watching to participating.
That’s what the whole song feels like: an attempt to construct something lasting out of fragments—TV images, half-remembered conversations, the emotional residue of growing up. The rockets go up, but the song stays grounded in what it felt like to watch them, to want something more without knowing exactly what that “more” was. Full body chills every time. Conor is my number three artist of all time, and Cape Canaveral is exactly why.
2. Leaving LA — Father John Misty
3. Cruiser — Red House Painters
4 (t). Houses on the Hill
4 (t). It’s Never Been a Fair Fight
5. Tulsa Queen — Emmylou Harris.
For years, Tulsa Queen was my answer. Greatest song ever. Number one. Don’t bother asking me again. And then, eventually, Cape Canaveral slipped past it. Barely. This isn’t really a demotion so much as the smallest possible movement inside the topmost tier: Tulsa Queen remains one of the most overwhelming pieces of music I have ever heard, and Emmylou Harris remains, for my money, the greatest vocalist who ever lived.
Then straight into:
I get full body chills and my eyes well up with tears every time I hear it…
The existing conclusion needs the corresponding tiny adjustment. Instead of “The GOAT. Pure legend. Full stop,” which contradicts #2, I’d go:
For a very long time, this was the GOAT. Now it is number two, which somehow feels both momentous and completely insignificant. Nothing about the song changed. I did. Pure legend. Forever.
I get full body chills and my eyes well up with tears every time I hear Tulsa Queen. Emmylou is the greatest vocalist of all time by far, and this song is the clearest possible evidence—not because it’s flashy or showy, but because it is so perfectly, devastatingly controlled. She doesn’t overpower the song; she becomes it. When she starts—“I saw the train/ in the Tulsa night/ calling out my name/ looking for a fight”—it’s just pure magic. The phrasing, the restraint, the sense that the story is already in motion before you’ve even arrived—there is nothing like it. You’re not being introduced to a narrative; you’re being dropped into the middle of one that already feels lived-in, already carries weight.
What makes Tulsa Queen so overwhelming is that it distills everything that makes Emmylou Harris who she is as an artist across her entire career: the fusion of country, folk, and rock sensibilities; the emotional clarity; the ability to inhabit a character without ever losing the self; the sense that every line has been earned. From her earliest work through her later records, she has always been able to locate the emotional center of a song with uncanny precision, but here she doesn’t just locate it—she holds it, perfectly, for the entire duration. It exists in the same emotional universe as something like “Boulder to Birmingham”—another wonderful, better-known masterpiece—but Tulsa Queen goes deeper.
Where “Boulder” is open grief, expansive and communal, Tulsa Queen is interior, private, almost dangerous in how close it lets you get to the narrator’s unrest. It feels less like a performance and more like a confession you were never meant to overhear. There are no words in any language to fully describe the feeling of listening to Tulsa Queen. That’s not hyperbole; it’s recognition. The song operates at a level that bypasses explanation and goes straight to the nervous system. It doesn’t ask to be analyzed—it insists on being felt. The GOAT. Pure legend. Full stop.
6. Faded — Afghan Whigs.
The Afghan Whigs lead singer Greg Dulli does something remarkable of Faded, which is blend swagger, menace, mystery, bravado, and also deep insecurity in one package. Seeing the Whigs play this as the encore at the Paradiso in Amsterdam in 2017 was one of the highlights of my life. It lands as an encore because it has to—it’s the only place a song like this can go. It doesn’t just end a set; it empties it out. Faded closes Black Love, which is not just an album but a fully realized world—cinematic, shadowy, saturated with urban crime, bad decisions, and the kind of late-night moral drift that never quite resolves.
Across the record, songs like Going to Town and Honky’s Ladder are all forward motion and attitude, pure swagger on the surface. But that swagger always feels a little overextended, like it’s covering something fragile underneath. By the time you get to Faded, the cover is gone. What’s been hinted at all along—doubt, damage, a kind of spiritual exhaustion—comes fully into view. There is no mystery as to why this has been the encore for every Whigs show for 30 years.
When Dulli asks to be lifted out of the night, to have someone look down and see the mess he’s in, it doesn’t feel performative. It feels exposed. The bravado is still there, but it’s cracked open, and what comes through is something far more human and far more dangerous. Not only is this the best Afghan Whigs song, Black Love is their best album by a mile. Everything they do well converges there—the mood, the storytelling, the tension between control and collapse—and Faded is the final, perfect release of that tension. He is a genius and the motherfucking man, and Faded is the best of many great Whigs songs. A worthy inclusion at number seven.
7. Dreadful — The Violet Burning
8. My Life Is Sweet — Simon Joyner.
“Met the drinker for a drink/ back when I was drinking everything but the kitchen sink”—and sure enough this song is about drinking, and drunks. Joyner’s friend is an alcoholic, and at the time of writing so is Joyner. They go to a bar and sit together, talking a little, mostly not, letting the night pass in that particular way that only two people who know each other well can manage.
Ultimately, this song is about male companionship, and how a quiet drink with a quiet friend can be life-saving when you really need it. Joyner takes a taxi home—drunk, or hungover, or somewhere in between—and collapses on the floor. And then the song ends with that extraordinary sequence where the city drops away, becomes something almost beautiful from a distance, and he arrives at that fragile, hard-won conclusion: my life is sweet. Anyone who is, or has been, a drinker will immediately recognize what Joyner is doing here—he is rationalizing the unrationalizable, but at the same time he’s not lying about it.
Is drinking so, so sweet? Yes and no, of course—and that tension is the point of this truly magnificent song. Part of what makes Joyner so compelling is how deeply rooted he is in the Omaha scene that would later produce Conor Oberst. Joyner is the elder figure there—born in 1971, a few years ahead of Oberst, who came up in the early ’80s generation—and his influence on Conor is both documented and unmistakable. Oberst has cited Joyner as a major influence, and you can hear it: the diaristic honesty, the willingness to let a song feel unfinished, the comfort with contradiction.
Joyner was mapping that terrain before it had a name, and before it had an audience beyond the local. He’s also massively underrated. He has other great songs—Fearful Man, One for the Catholic Girls—but My Life Is Sweet feels like the purest distillation of what he does best. There’s no artifice, no attempt to resolve the contradictions he’s living inside. Just a voice, a night, a friend, and the uneasy grace of getting through it. Anyone who’s been there knows: that’s more than enough.
9. Never Aim to Please — Tommy Stinson
Tommy Stinson, the bassist from The Replacements—went on to have, in my opinion, an even better solo career than the band’s lead singer Paul Westerberg. And considering that Westerberg is a genius and an absolute legend, this is saying something.
Stinson was barely out of childhood when the Replacements were at their peak—a teenager holding down the low end in one of the most chaotic, brilliant bands of their era. That early immersion shows up everywhere in his later work: the instinct for melody, the looseness, the sense that a song should feel lived-in rather than perfected. But what’s striking about his post-Replacements career—through Bash & Pop and his solo records—is how much he refines that instinct. The pure thrash and glorious sloppiness of early Replacements material gives way to something sweeter, more polished, but never sanitized. The edges are still there; they’re just better framed.
Never Aim to Please comes from Bash & Pop’s first record, Friday Night Is Killing Me, and Stinson has alternated between Bash & Pop releases and solo records over the 35 years since the Replacements broke up. In the first verse, Stinson sings about the absence of a point of view, and that marvelous line always reminds me of Westerberg’s writing on “Someone Take the Wheel”—that same sense of dislocation, of trying to find footing in a world that keeps shifting under you. There’s a great anecdote from Westerberg that early on, the Replacements pretended to hate The Rolling Stones—it was part of the pose, the punk posture. But it was just that: a pose. They actually loved the Stones.
And you can hear that lineage clearly in Stinson’s work. For all of his originality, he’s very much working in that classic rock tradition—songcraft, groove, emotional directness—but he does it in the best possible way, without nostalgia or mimicry. It feels inherited, not borrowed. Stinson may not claim to have a point of view in this song, but he’s been a remarkable curator and keeper of the Replacements’ legacy, especially as Westerberg has retreated from the music scene over the last decade. There’s a quiet authority in that, a sense of continuity that runs through his work. And the song itself? It just fucking kicks. It hits me in all the feels every time, and it is a worthy number nine.
10. The Traitor — Leonard Cohen
Cohen’s early career began not as a songwriter but as a poet and novelist—already established in literary circles before he ever stepped into popular music. When he moved into song, it wasn’t a reinvention so much as a translation. Early breakthroughs like Suzanne and later Bird on the Wire introduced a voice that felt unlike anything in contemporary pop: formally literary, emotionally restrained, but spiritually enormous.
Across a career that stretches from that early poetic minimalism to late-period gravity, Cohen repeatedly returned to the same emotional territory in different registers. Seems So Long Ago, Nancy carries quiet tragedy without spectacle. Death of a Ladies’ Man leans into chaos and contradiction. Alexandra Leaving and That Don’t Make It Junk show a late-career clarity—less ornament, more acceptance. And then, right at the end, The Night of Santiago from Thank You for the Dance—completed after his death by his son Adam—feels like a final echo rather than a conclusion, as if the voice is still resolving even after it has stopped.
But it is this passage that sits at the center of everything: “I told my mother, mother I must leave you / preserve my room and do not shed a tear / should rumor of a shabby ending reach you / it was half my fault and half the atmosphere.” Quite possibly the greatest verse ever set to paper.
There is something almost unbearable in its tenderness—the attempt to leave without destroying what you came from, to depart without turning departure into permanent damage. “Preserve my room” is not a realistic request; it is a desire for time to stop, for memory to remain untouched while the self moves forward into uncertainty, drift, and likely failure.
Cohen does something very few writers ever manage: he distributes responsibility without dissolving it. “Half my fault and half the atmosphere” is not an excuse—it is an ethics of existence. The self is accountable, but so is the world that formed it. There is guilt here, but no self-pity. There is clarity, but no absolution. He is naming the condition of being human with a precision that feels almost too large to hold. And what makes the song extraordinary is that it refuses resolution. Cohen never tries to solve the tension he has introduced. Instead, he inhabits it fully.
Across his work—from the early poetic breakthrough to the late songs of acceptance and erosion—he speaks to the quester, the striver, the poet, and the mystic in each of us. Not by offering answers, but by dignifying the act of searching itself. Leaving, longing, failing, seeking—these are not problems to resolve, but conditions to endure with awareness. His voice carries all of it: resignation, yearning, and a kind of quiet, unbreakable grace.
His best by a mile. Simply marvelous.
11. A Bathtub in the Kitchen — Craig Finn.
My favorite of many possible Finn contenders. Bathtub is about friendship, guilt, redemption, betrayal, and mostly about thankfulness. It’s the greatest song ever written about New York City and also about moving to a big city in general. Finn compresses an entire early chapter of a life into a few lines—the arrival, the uncertainty, the desperation to be claimed by the city, and the friend who makes that possible by opening his door. That friend—Francis—is the emotional center of the song. Twenty years earlier, he’s the one who shows the narrator the ropes, lets him crash on the couch, gives him a foothold when he doesn’t have one. He is, in a very real sense, the reason the narrator makes it at all. And now, in the present of the song, Francis is down and out, struggling, a diminished version of the figure who once seemed stable and generous.
What makes the song hit so hard is the narrator’s response to that reversal. There’s hesitation, even avoidance. He tries, briefly, to pass the responsibility off—to suggest that someone else, someone more put-together, might be in a better position to help. It’s a small moment, almost throwaway, but it reveals everything: the discomfort, the guilt, the instinct to deflect when confronted with a debt that can’t really be repaid. Because that’s the truth the song circles around—some debts can’t be repaid. Not cleanly, not proportionally.
In the end, the narrator does give Francis money—two hundred bucks—but it lands with a kind of quiet insufficiency. It’s something, but it’s not enough, and it never could be. You can’t square that kind of ledger. You can only acknowledge it. And that’s where the thankfulness comes in. Not as a resolution, not as a way of tying things up neatly, but as a recognition that what was given mattered, even if what is returned will always fall short. Finn doesn’t offer redemption in the traditional sense. He offers something more honest: awareness, discomfort, and the attempt—however partial—to do right by someone who once did right by you. It’s a stunning, stunning song and an absolutely worthy number nine.
12. Gorgeous (live)— The Violet Burning
13. Albuquerque — Neil Young (Mark Kozelek Cover)
14. Oh My Sweet Carolina — Ryan Adams
One of the most beautiful and sad songs in modern American songwriting. The record Heartbreaker—Adams’ solo debut after his run fronting Whiskeytown—remains his peak for many listeners. It’s also the album where everything still feels unforced: the writing, the pacing, the emotional exposure. Later records like Gold brought wider recognition, and something like Chris gets close in flashes, but Heartbreaker has a coherence of mood that he never quite replicated.
What defines Oh My Sweet Carolina is its dual perspective. On the surface, it’s a travel song—young man on the road, drifting through cities like Cleveland, accumulating damage, spending energy and money with a kind of reckless momentum that feels both chosen and inevitable. But underneath that motion is something much older: a pull backward, toward origin, toward a place that isn’t just geographic but emotional. North Carolina isn’t just home—it’s coherence.
The Cleveland passages (“So I went on to Cleveland and I ended up insane/ I bought a borrowed suit and learned to dance/ And I was spending money like the way it likes to rain/ Man, I ended up with pockets full of cane”) carry that classic Ryan Adams contradiction: charm and collapse in the same breath. The narrator moves through instability with the confidence of someone still convinced that motion equals meaning, even as that belief is starting to fail him. It’s the sound of someone learning, mid-stream, that movement alone doesn’t resolve anything. And then the emotional center of the song reveals itself: (Oh mw sweet Carolina/ what compels me to go/ oh, my sweet disposition/ may you one day carry me home), the longing not just to return, but to be returned in one piece. Not improved, not transformed—just intact.
This is where the collaboration with Emmylou Harris matters. Her voice doesn’t decorate the song; it stabilizes it. It sounds like witness. Adams has written other songs that brush this same emotional territory—English Girls Approximately, Oh My God, Whatever, Etc., Still a Cage, Birmingham—but none of them quite hold the same balance of youth and exhaustion, romance and reckoning. Oh My Sweet Carolina feels like a hinge between those states: a young man already speaking like he understands what the older version of himself will miss. It’s a debut record moment that feels strangely final. A song about going forward that only makes sense when you understand what it costs to leave things behind. A truly majestic entry—and a worthy entry here at fifteen.
15. (T) Montreal Rock Band Somewhere — Happyness
15. (T) Crushed Out — Bad Moves
17. Caribbean Wind — Bob Dylan
18. Center of Asia — Paul Pena
19. Rocket and a Bomb — Michael Knott.
This is Knott’s best-known—and, for many people, only known—song. It’s the one that traveled beyond the small, fractured world he spent his career navigating, the one that people who don’t know the rest of his catalog can still recognize. And that’s fitting, because it captures almost everything that made him singular. Knott never fit comfortably inside the Christian rock community that was supposed to be his home. He clashed with labels, bounced from one situation to another, tried repeatedly to start his own imprints just to maintain control of his work, and spent much of his career existing in the margins of an already marginal scene. There were too many expectations, too many rules about what a “Christian artist” was supposed to sound like, what he was supposed to say, how cleanly he was supposed to resolve things. Knott refused all of it.
You can hear the lineage—artists like Larry Norman laid some of the groundwork—but Knott is no inheritor in the traditional sense. He’s a total original. Where Norman and others often leaned toward proclamation, Knott leaned into contradiction, mess, unresolved tension. He wasn’t interested in presenting faith as an answer; he was interested in showing what it felt like to live inside it when the answers didn’t come.
His career reflects that restlessness. From the early chaos of Popsicle and Popsavers, through the darker, more aggressive phases of L.S. Underground and LSU, into his solo work and projects like Aunt Betty’s, Knott kept shifting forms, refusing to settle into anything that could be easily categorized. The sound changed, the bands changed, the labels changed—but the core impulse didn’t: tell the truth as he experienced it, even if it didn’t line up with what anyone wanted to hear. Rocket and a Bomb distills all of that into something deceptively simple. There’s humor in it, almost absurdity—“Mr. God, is there a Ms. God? Can she help me find a job?”—but it lands because it’s so nakedly real. This is a man of Christ who is also a man of the world, standing in the gap between those identities, not reconciling them but living them both at once. He’s not asking for salvation in the abstract; he’s asking for something immediate, practical, human. He just needs a goddam job.
That tension runs through everything he ever said and did. His line—“I know Christ. It doesn’t make me good; it doesn’t make me bad; it doesn’t make me anything. It just means I know Christ.”—might be the clearest articulation of his entire ethos. Faith is not a moral upgrade, not a solution, not a transformation you can point to and quantify. It’s a relationship, and relationships are messy. So what is a rocket and a bomb? They’re things most people don’t get to touch. Power, transcendence, impact—forces that exist beyond the everyday. The narrator wants a job, something stable, something achievable. But he also wants more. He wants access to something larger, something explosive, something that breaks the limits of an ordinary life. Knott lived that contradiction. He lived fast, pushed hard, refused to smooth out the edges that made him difficult to categorize or contain. He burned through systems that couldn’t hold him, left behind a body of work that feels both deeply personal and strangely universal. He had to.
20. There Must Be More Than Blood — Car Seat Headrest.
This is a tricky one, because it forces us to deal with a shift—not just in a song, but in an artist. My thesis is that this is Will Toledo going into a kind of relative hiding, and the song reads like a document of that transition in real time. His early work—from Beach Life-in-Death through Nervous Young Man to Sleeping with Strangers—was as direct, as exposed, as heart-on-the-sleeve as anything in the last decade of rock music. He wasn’t just confessional; he was incapable of not being confessional. He was the heart on his sleeve songwriter of his generation. You didn’t have to work to understand him—you just had to be willing to feel what he was feeling.
And then you put that next to someone like John Darnielle—super prolific, deeply lofi in his early approach, but always a little more mediated, a little more constructed. Darnielle throws his material against the wall and lets it accumulate into narrative. Toledo, at his best, just bleeds. So when Making a Door Less Open arrives, even the title signals a shift. Something is closing. Something is being sealed off. The masks—first the normal face coverings, then the Trait mask, then the gas mask—aren’t just stagecraft. They’re statements. The question isn’t “what is he hiding?” but “why does he suddenly feel the need to hide at all?” There Must Be More Than Blood sits right in the middle of that tension. You get these images of dislocation—of a life that used to feel rooted and now doesn’t. The delta, the shoreline, the houses stripped away—it doesn’t read like a literal disaster so much as an internal one. The sense of ground disappearing. Of structures—family, identity, whatever “home” used to mean—losing their coherence. He talks about wasting time, but you know that’s not true. He’s one of the most prolific songwriters around. What he’s really describing is a shift in how that time feels from the inside.
And then there’s the second movement—the red-eye flight, the self-recognition that barely qualifies as recognition at all. He sees himself, but only as an outline, a set of lines without substance. That’s the real break from the early work. The old Toledo was hyper-present, almost overwhelmingly so. This Toledo is thinning out, becoming harder even for himself to locate. So what do you do when you can’t see yourself clearly anymore? You disappear further. You become, in a sense, the Invisible Man. That’s what the masks start to feel like—not affectation, but adaptation. A way of dealing with a self that no longer feels stable enough to present directly. And if you follow that thread forward, you get to The Scholars—The Scholars—his most recent record. It’s even more oblique than Door. There are great songs there—Stay With Me (I Don’t Want to Be Alone), Equals—but they’re harder to parse, less immediately accessible. The emotional core is still there, but it’s buried deeper, refracted through more layers.
Part of that may simply be life catching up with him. Toledo dealt with serious health issues in the lead-up to that record—long COVID, histamine intolerance—and the process became more collaborative, less singularly driven. That alone changes the texture of the work. The lone voice becomes one voice among several. The signal diffuses.So There Must Be More Than Blood starts to feel like a hinge point. The moment where the old mode—pure exposure, pure immediacy—begins to give way to something more guarded, more fragmented, more difficult to access. But the core hasn’t disappeared. It’s just harder to reach. And that’s why the song matters. It captures an artist in the act of losing something essential—or at least transforming it into something less direct, less available, maybe even less comforting. Will Toledo is a mysterious guy. Deep, fragile, a little haunted, clearly carrying more than he lets on. He’s dealt with some tough stuff, and you can feel it in the way the work shifts over time. And for anyone still saying “rock is dead”—they can fuck off. There is still The Hold Steady and Car Seat Headrest making records that matter, records that wrestle with something real. You just have to be willing to meet them where they are now, not where they used to be.
21. Stay the Same — Home
22 (t). Killer Parties — The Hold Steady
Everything else is commentary. The band isn’t just a band; Finn isn’t just a frontman. The Hold Steady is a community, a lineage, a shared memory palace built out of long nights, near-misses, inside jokes, loud guitars, and people who actually want to be there. We are the Hold Steady. And Craig baby you are goddamn right, I am the Hold Steady. The Hold Steady is my favorite rock band of all time. I could make the case for a few others—The Velvet Underground, Grateful Dead, The Replacements, Car Seat Headrest—but for my money The Hold Steady most cleanly expresses what rock music is for. Not just sound, not just attitude, but shared experience turned into narrative.
Coming out of Lifter Puller, Finn was already writing in tight, clipped internal rhymes, dense alliteration, and nocturnal fragmentation. But with The Hold Steady the perspective opens up. The chaos is still there, but it’s filtered through memory and reflection. The language becomes more legible without losing its edge. Killer Parties, from the 2003 debut Almost Killed Me, is told from the perspective of someone older, someone who has already lived through the hardcore-to-indie-to-rave-up continuum and come out the other side. He’s been through Minneapolis basements, New York nights, Ybor City mythologies—the so-called party capital of America—and what remains is not nostalgia exactly, but accounting.
What did it cost, and what did it mean? It pairs naturally with Most People Are DJs (“I was a Twin City trash bin / I’d jam it all into my system”) and Soft in the Center (“And I’m just trying to tell the truth, kid / I’m just trying to tell the truth / You can’t get every girl / You get the ones you love the best”). Across these songs, Finn is already moving toward the older register he occupies now: less urgency, more reckoning. Like Faded in the Afghan Whigs canon, Killer Parties has remained a live staple—an encore song, a release valve, a communal shoutback. And its central refrain is exactly what it says it is: killer parties almost killed me.
No metaphor is needed beyond that. Finn has been there and done that. He has lived it, absorbed it, and returned from it with something closer to clarity than regret. And even in this early form, you can already hear the direction of travel: toward the reflective, grounded, older voice that defines him now. A truly great song—and a blueprint for what comes after the chaos stops being infinite.
22 (t). Leave the City -— Jason Molina (Live)
August 2026 New Top 250 Work in Progress:
1. Cape Canaveral — Conor Oberst
- Leaving LA — Father John Misty
- Cruiser — Red House Painters
4t. It’s Never Been a Fair Fight — Craig Finn
4t. Houses on the Hill — Whiskeytown
- Tulsa Queen — Emmylou Harris
- Faded — Afghan Whigs
- Dreadful — The Violet Burning
- My Life Is Sweet — Simon Joyner
- Never Aim to Please — Tommy Stinson
- The Traitor — Leonard Cohen
- A Bathtub in the Kitchen — Craig Finn
- Gorgeous — The Violet Burning
- Albuquerque — Neil Young (Mark Kozelek Cover)
- Oh My Sweet Carolina — Ryan Adams
- (15T) Montreal Rock Band Somewhere — Happyness
- (15T) Crushed Out — Bad Moves
- Caribbean Wind — Bob Dylan
- Center of Asia — Paul Pena
- Rocket and a Bomb — Michael Knott
- There Must Be More Than Blood — Car Seat Headrest
- Stay the Same —Home
- Leave the City — Jason Molina (Live)
- Killer Parties (live 2008) — The Hold Steady
- Roll Another Number for the Road — Neil Young
- Between Planets — The Jesus and Mary Chain
- Jessamine — Craig Finn
- Catfish John — Jerry Garcia
- My Life in Art — Mojave 3
- Red River Shore — Bob Dylan
- Three Drinks — Craig Finn
- Thrasher — Neil Young
- Faithless Street — Whiskeytown
- Double — Michael Knott
- My Life in Art — Mojave 3
- Julia With Blue Jeans On — Moonface
- Malibu Love Nest — Luna
- Lovesick — The Violet Burning
- Lisa Says — The Velvet Underground
- Trains Across the Sea — The Silver Jews
- The Man I’ve Always Been — Craig Finn
- Sugar Mama — Michael Knott
- Have You Forgotten — Red House Painters
- SB’s Truck — Happyness
- Violent Past — Low
- An Architect’s Eye — The Mendoza Line
- No One Changes — Conor Oberst
- Ain’t Gonna Suck Itself — Cracker
- Traveling Light — The Tindersticks
- I Love My Dad — Sun Kil Moon
- Blood of Eden — Peter Gabriel
- Easy / Lucky / Free — Bright Eyes (BOCC Cover)
- Kill the Action — East River Pipe
- Ali/Spinks II — Sun Kil Moon
- Rock n’ Singer — AC/DC (Mark Kozelek Cover)
- Chinatown — Luna
- Can’t Hardly Wait — The Replacements
- Goshen ’97 — Strand of Oaks
- Tiny Pieces — Bash and Pop
- Standing on the Moon — Phosphorescent (Grateful Dead Cover)
- Julia With Blue Jeans On — Moonface
- Schizophrenia — Sonic Youth
- Tougher Than the Rest — (Mendoza Line (Bruce Springsteen Cover)
- Goodbye — Steve Earle (Emmylou Harris Cover)
- Nobody But You — Lou Reed and John Cale
- Driving the Dynamite Truck — Seam (Breaking Circus Cover)
- Cortez the Killer — Neil Young (Church Cover)
- Must Have Been the Roses — The Grateful Dead
- Love Songs on the Radio — Mojave 3
- Black Cab — Jens Lekman
- It’s a Long Line (But It Moves Quickly) — The Mendoza Line
- 31 Candles — The Mendoza Line
- Shelter Me — Poison
- I Drink — Mary Gauthier
- Cherry Chapstick — Yo La Tengo
- Drag Queens and Limousines — Mary Gauthier
- Against Pollution — The Mountain Goats
- Jokerman — Bob Dylan
- Wish You Were Here — Pink Floyd (Sparklehorse Cover)
- Tired Eyes — Neil Young
- Death of a Ladies’ Man — Leonard Cohen
- Look at Miss Ohio — Gillian Welch
- April the 14th Part II — Gillian Welch
- Thirty Year Low — The Mendoza Line
- Black and Brown Blues — Silver Jews
- I’m Sorry — John Denver (Red House Painters Cover)
- (T) The Lights of Magdala — Kris Kristofferson (Red House Painters Cover)
- (T) Car Wash Hair — Mercury Rev (Luna Cover)
- Suffering Jukebox — Silver Jews
- Pissed Off 3 AM — Alejandro Escovedo
- Someone Take the Wheel — The Replacements
- Teenage Riot — Sonic Youth
- (T) New Sensations (Live) — Lou Reed
- Head On — The Jesus and Mary Chain
- After Your Party — Tanya Donelly
- This Isn’t It — Giant Drag
- Shut In — Strand of Oaks
- Anna Lisa Says — Happyness
- Song for Dennis Brown — The Mountain Goats
- Never Say Goodbye — Bob Dylan
- Snowin’ on Raton — Townes Van Zandt
- 1979 — Smashing Pumpkins
- All Rooms A/C Cable Free — The Extra Glens
- An Harangue — The Red Krayola and Art and Language
- Sunday Morning Comin’ Down — Kris Kristofferson
- California — Low
- Green Eyes — Nick Cave
- Dead Flowers (Live)— The Rolling Stones
- Star 18 — The Hold Steady
- Crime in the Desert — Brian Eno/ John Cale
- Street Hassle — Lou Reed
- Schizophrenia — Sonic Youth
- Day Disguise — Hope Sandoval
- San Francisco B.C. — Silver Jews
- Barstool — Neil Young
- Most of the Time — Bob Dylan (Luna Cover)
- Brownsville Girl— Bob Dylan
- Two Sons in the Sunset — Pink Floyd
- Pale Green Things — The Mountain Goats
- What Would the Community Think — Cat Power
- Sweet Child O’ Mine — Guns N’ Roses
- Feed the Tree — Belly
- Up to Me — Bob Dylan
- (T) One Man’s Rubbish — The Beautiful South
- (T) Foreign Object — The Mountain Goats
- Hatchet — Low
- Song to the Siren — This Mortal Coil
- Kate’s Guitar — Greg Brown
- Good as Gold — The Beautiful South
- Ben’s My Friend — Sun Kil Moon
- Triumph 73 — The Felice Brothers
- Oh Sister — Bob Dylan
- Awesome Sound— Ween
- Dr. Rock — Ween
- Harbourcoat — REM
- Kavita — Red House Painters
- Screenwriter’s School — Craig Finn
- Darken Your Door — Camper Van Beethoven (Also Richmond Version)
- Different Days — Jason Isabel
- A Dream — Lou Reed and John Cale
- Hollywood Lawn — Jenny Lewis
- A Little Uncanny — Conor Obrest
- Claim to Fame — Alex Chilton
- Terrified Eyes — Craig Finn
- Evelyn Is Not Real — My Morning Jacket
- Didn’t Know What I Was In For — Better Oblivion Community Center
- Little Chang, Big City — Seam
- Teenage Wristband — The Twilight Singers
- Phone Went West (live at the 9:30 Club)— My Morning Jacket
- Corpus Christie Bay — Phosphorescent
- Guitar Town — Steve Earle
- (T) Atlantic City — East River Pipe
- (T) I’m Not (live)— Daddy Issues
- Welfare State — Slow Dazzle
- Misunderstood — Wilco
- The Violet Hour — The Clientele
- Dallas — Silver Jews
- Seems So Long Ago, Nancy — Leonard Cohen
- That Don’t Make it Junk — Leonard Cohen
- Hard Time — Daniel Johnston
- Southern Accents — Tom Petty (Lucinda Williams Cover)
- First Blood — The Mountain Goats
- Chameleon — Michael Knott
- Tether to Tassel — Michael Knott
- Who Knows Where the Time Goes — Nina Simone
- Pretty in Pink— The Psychedelic Furs
- (T) Fall of Saigon — Elliott Murphy
- (T) Two Places at Once — The Church
- UFO — Larry Norman
- Pay for Me — The National
- Stroke it Noel — Big Star
- (T) Classic Cars — Conor Oberst
- Oh My Soul — Big Star
- (T) Lofts — Happyness
- Summer of the Whore — Shannon McArdle
- Elastic Days — J. Mascis
- Nickel and a Spoon — Alejandro Escavedo
- What’s a Simple Man to Do? — Steve Earle
- Seen the Light — Giant Drag
- Lyin’ Eyes — The Eagles
- Mercedes Benz — Janis Joplin
- Weighted Down — Skip Spence
- Bangkok — Alex Chilton
- (T) Out There — Dinosaur Jr.
- Feel the Pain — Dinosaur Jr.
- (T) Cherry Bomb — The Runaways
- (T) Personality Crisis — New York Dolls
- JM— Strand of Oaks
- The Likely Nominee— The Mendoza Line
- The Bear — My Morning Jacket
- Hula Hula Boys — Warren Zevon
- Tennessee — The Silver Jews
- Red Right Hand — Nick Cave
- Buckets of Rain — Bob Dylan
- Jim Jones — Bob Dylan
- Tiny Tears — Tindersticks
- Kangaroo — This Mortal Coil
- Sabotage — Papa M
- (T) In Spite of Me — Morphine
- (T) See You at the Movies— J. Mascis
- Blow Him Apart — The Felice Brothers
- Crime In the City — Neil Young
- She’s Lost Control — Joy Division
- The Myth of Fingerprints— Paul Simon
- Keep On Rockin’ In the Free World — Neil Young
- The Boxer — Simon and Garfunkeltzz a
- Shelter from the Storm — Bob Dylan
- Winter Games — Superchunk
- Top Floor Bottom Buzzer — Morphine
- Richard Ramirez Died Today of Natural Causes — Sun Kil Moon
- Scum — Nick Cave
- Buffalo Ballet — John Cale
- Sidewalk — Superchunk
- Storms — Fleetwood Mac (Camper Van Beethoven Cover)
- Heaven Sitting Down — Phosphorescent
- Desperadoes Under The Eaves — Warren Zevon
- Frankie’s Gun — The Felice Brothers
- Slack Mothefucker — Superchunk
- Teenage Kicks — The Undertones
- FOH — Superchunk
- The Alphonse Mambo — The Mountain Goats
- The Church of the Holy Spook — Shane McGowan
- I Fought the Law — The Clash
- No Time to Cry — Iris DeMent
- Tangled Up in Blue — Bob Dylan
- Terror in the Canyons — Phosphorescent
- I Don’t Wanna Get Over You — The Magnetic Fields
- Goddamn Lonely Love — The Drive By Truckers
- Train — Michael Knott
- Days of Our Years — The Felice Brothers
- Rocks Off — The Rolling Stones
- Achin’ to Be — The Replacements
- Sell the House — The Felice Brothers
- (T) Death or Glory — The Clash
- (T) Sultans of Swing — Dire Sraits
- Bodys — Car Seat Headrest
- All the Wine — The National
- Come In From the Cold — Joni Mitchell
- I Walk a Thin Line — (Fleetwood Mac Cover)
- Fill in the Blank — Car Seat Headrest
- Out For the Killing — Elliott Murphy
- Easy’s CfGetting Harder Every Day — Iris DeMent
- Anything Can Happen — Bash and Pop
- Newmyer’s Roof — Craig Finn
- Charley’s Girl — Lou Reed
- The Man in Me — Bob Dylan
- Going to Town — The Afghan Whigs
- My Life Is Wrong — East River Pipe
- Tangletown — Craig Finn
- Lord Kill the Pain — Red House Painters
- (T) Silhouette Town — East River Pipe
- (T) Next of Kin — Conor Obrest
- Gold Mine Gutted — Conor Obrest
- God in Chicago — Craig Finn
- Mistakes Were Made — The Mendoza Line
- I Hate Rock n’ Roll — The Jesus and Mary Chain
- Shark Smile — Big Thief
- Another Day — This Mortal Coil (Roy Harper Cover)
- Yesterday — Mark Sandman
- Glasgow Eyes — The Jesus and Mary Chain
- The Stallion I-V — Ween
- Foreign Hotel Garden — Papa M
- Local Boy Makes Good — Papa M
- Duty Free — Cracker
- 40 Miles — East River Pipe
- Mutineer — Warren Zevon
- Five Green Queens and Jean — Shane McGowan
- I Love Rock n’ Roll — The Jesus and Mary Chain
- Stop Whaling — Happyness
- Tiny Dancer — Elton John
- Teenage Kicks — The Undertones
- Hotel California — The Eagles
- Take It Easy — The Eagles
- Going to California — Led Zeppelin
- Casper the Friendly Ghost — Daniel Johnston
- You Can Call Me Al — Paul Simon
- Red Rain — Peter Gabriel
- Float On — Modest Mouse
- Undress — The Felice Brothers
- Ocean Man — Ween
- Camp Pendleton — Camper Van Beethoven
- Skyway — The Replacements
- Nothing Compares to You — Sinead O’Conner
- One More of Coffee — Bob Dylan
- Lawyers Guns and Money— Warren Zevon
- Rexroth’s Daughter— Greg Brown
- City Sickness — The Tindersticks
- Black Diamond Bay — Bob Dylan
- Gustavo— Sun Kil Moon
- Lily Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts — Bob Dylan
- Aspect of an Old Maid — The Mendoza Line
- It Was Like That When We Got There — Camper Van Beethoven
- Mr. Bad Example — Warren Zevon
- Song for Zula — Phosphorescent
- Rebel Rebel — David Bowie
- A New England — Phosphorescent
- On the Rocks — Bash and Pop
- Out on the Weekend — Neil Young
- Unknown Legend — Neil Young
- Sweet Jane — Velvet Underground
- Don’t Go Back to Rockville — REM
- Honky Tonk Woman — The Rolling Stones
- Moon Radio — The Violet Burning
- Waiting for My Man — The Velvet Underground
- Lost in the Supermarket — The Clash
- King Rides By — Cat Power
- Speed Trap Town — Jason Isabel
- Most People Are DJs — The Hold Steady
- Berlin Kitty — The Violet Burning
- (T) Outta My System — My Morning Jacket
- (T) Jonah — Wussy
- These Three Days — Lucinda Williams
- Soft in the Center — The Hold Steady
- Lonesome L.A. Cowboy — Peter Rowan
- Sugercube— Yo La Tengo
- (T) The Buff and the Flex Result — Lifter Puller
- (T) Language City — Wolf Parade
- On the Beach — Neil Young
- Yesterday — Mark Sandman
- Million Dollar Bill— Dawes (Conor Obrest Cover)
- The Boom Boom Lounge — Michael Knott
- Dylan Thomas — Better Oblivion Community Center
- The Flames Are Coming Back — East River Pipe
- This Year — The Mountain Goats
- Slapped Actress — The Hold Steady
- Eye of Fatima — Camper Van Beethoven
- I’ll Be Your Handbag— Shane McGowan
- Orange Crush — REM
- Copperhead Road — Steve Earle
- (T) Small Town Napoleons — The Mendoza Line
- (T) Toy Automatic — The Afghan Whigs
- Mission Veajo — Lifter Puller
- Big Day Coming (Acoustic and Electric) Yo La Tengo
- Guts — John Cale
- From the Right Angle — Dawes
- All Apologies — Sinead O’ Conner (Nirvana Cover)
- Song for Whoever — The Beautiful South
- What’s Going On — Marvin Gaye
- From a Window Seat — Dawes
- Seven Languages — Camper Van Beethoven
- Rain Street — Shane McGowan
- Detroit Has a Skyline — Superchunk
- Ocean Man – Ween
- Gardening at Night — REM
- Always Crashing in the Same Car — David Bowie
- Watching the Wheels — John Lennon
- Jane — The Aunt Bettys
- Working Class Hero — John Lennon
- The Week of Living Dangerously — Steve Earle
- Michigan — Red House Painters
- Berlitz — Seam
- Jesus — The Aunt Bettys
- Police and Thieves — Junior Murvin (Clash cover)
- Shine a Light — Rolling Stones
- Letter to Eloise — The Cure
- Kevin is Gay — Giant Drag
- Rock n’ Roll — Velvet Underground
- (T) Just Like the Tom Thumb Blues — Bob Dylan
- (T) Halloween Parade — Lou Reed
- (T) I’m Not (live) — Daddy Issues
- Esther — The Hold Steady
- Paul is Dead — Yo La Tengo
- Honkey’s Ladder — The Afghan Whigs
- We Shall Live Again — The Felice Brothers
- Plymouth — Strand of Oaks
- Suzy Lighting— Warren Zevon
- Rented Rooms — Tindersticks
- The Rockaways — Conor Oberst
- End of the Line — The Traveling Wilburys
- Shooting Star — Bob Dylan
- Spinners — The Hold Steady
- Wonderful Life — The Felice Brothers
- Close to Me— The Cure
- Girl From Oregon Hill — David Lowrey
- Everybody Get a Fucking Day Job— David Lowrey
- Where’d the Cheese Go— Ween
- The Sick Bed of Culcahian— The Pogues
- An Unguarded Moment — The Church
- Come Dancing — The Kinks
- Carmelita — Warren Zevon
- Sound and Vision — David Bowie
- Everybody’s Talkin’ — Harry Neilson
- Madame George — Van Morrison
- You Shook Me All Night Long — AC/DC
- Aaron’s Getting Poopy — Michael Knott
- Raspberry Beret — Prince
- Sixers — The Hold Steady
- Gotta Get Drunk — Phosphorescent
- 36D — The Beautiful South
- Clampdown — The Clash
- Lay Lady Lay — Bob Dylan
- Thunder Road —Bruce Springsteen
- Shattered — The Rolling Stones
- Jan the Weatherman — Michael Knott
- The Way They Murdered Me — East River Pipe
- Sequestered In Memphis — The Hold Steady
- The Mermaid Parade — Phosphorescent
- Star Star — The Rolling Stones
- Once Upon a Time in the West – Dire Straits
- Requiem for Dying Mothers Part I and II — Stars of the Lid
- Leaving Haringey — The Clientele
- Sweet Virginia — Rolling Stones
- I Was So Bad — The Red Crayola
- How Do You Sleep — John Lennon
- Pass the Wine — John Lennon
- Just for You — The Church
- Hanky Panky Nohow — John Cale
- She Came In Through the Bathroom Window — The Beatles
- Jealous Guy — John Lennon
- Fairytale of New York— The Pogues
- Bluebird of Happiness — Mojave 3
- Available — The National
- The Legend of Chavo Guerrero — The Mountain Goats
- Japanese to English — The Red House Painters
- Anybody Else — Bash and Pop
- Sugar for the Pill — Slowdive
- Headed for the Door — Moonface
- Slow Slow — The National
- Sarah — Mojave 3
- Jacking the Ball — The Sea and Cake
- Daysleeper — REM
- Alex Chilton — The Replacements
- The Fall of the High School Running Back — The Mountain Goats
- Rafael — Seam
- I Met the Stones — Dinosaur Jr.
- Stuck Between Stations — The Hold Steady
- Holidays in the Sun — The Sex Pistols
- Friday I’m In Love — The Cure
- Bad Doctor — The Mountain Goats
- Every Rose Has It’s Thorn — Poison
- Here’s to Your Fuck — The Gits
- Push the Lil’ Daisies — Ween
- Career Opportunities — The Clash
- Ninety Miles and Hour (Down a Dead End Street) — Bob Dylan
- I Live in LA — Camper Van Beethoven
- Ballad of John and Yoko — The Beatles
- The Last Days of Our Acquaintance — Sinead O’Conner
- Back in the USSR— The Beatles
- Bouncing Round the Room — Phish
- Early Man — Mark Sandman
- God Save the Queen — The Sex Pistols
- Your Latest Trick — Dire Straits
- Mistaken for Strangers — The National
- Jet Plane — The Popsavers
- Come Together — The Beatles
- Caught Beneath Your Heel — Mojave 3
- Like a Rolling Stone — Bob Dylan
- Teary Eyes Bloody Lips — Moonface
- Oh La La — John Cale
- Talent Show — The Replacements
- Autobiography — John Cale
- Whole Wide World — Wreckless Eric
- (T) The Amarillo Kid — Craig Finn
- Diamond Joe — Bob Dylan
- Watch Yo Screw — DJ Screw
- Inferno — The Felice Brothers
- Janie Jones — The Clash
- (T) Suspicious Minds —Elvis Presley (My Morning Jacket Cover)
- Barnaby Hardly Working — Yo La Tengo
- Answering Machine — The Replacements
- Unsatisfied — The Replacements
- Nice Nice — Lifter Puller
- (T) I Wanna Be Sedated —The Ramones
- (T) Spaced Cowboy — Sly and the Family Stone
- Hard Times — Bob Dylan
- Artificial Flowers — The Beautiful South
- Ugly Flower Pretty Vase — Moonface
- Dungtitled in a Major — Stars of the Lid
- Thursday — Morphine
- Bastards of Young — The Replacements
- Radio Song — The Felice Brothers
- One In a Million — Guns N’ Roses
- Sailin’ da South — DJ Screw
- Friends in Low Places — Garth Brooks
- Carry Bag Man — The Fall
- Cardinal Song — The National
- Girl from Ipanema — Astrud Gilberto
- Where is the Love — Mojave 3
- No Divorce — The Mountain Goats
- Countess From Hong Kong — Velvet Underground
- Mon Desir — The Violet Burning
- Low Budget — The Kinks
- TB Sheets — Van Morrison
- Rocket Man — Elton John (My Morning Jacket)
- November Rain — Guns N’ Roses
- Beat on the Brat — The Ramones
- Washington Bullets — The Clash
- Man Without Ties — Paul Westerberg
- Brown Eyed Girl — Van Morrison
- Brown Eyed Handsome Man — Chuck Berry
- Love’s Gonna Get’cha (Material Love) — KRS One
- Band on the Run — Paul McCartney
- The Trouble With Classicists— Lou Reed and John Cale
- Rape Me — Nirvana
- Froggie Went a Courting
- Black Boys on Mopeds — Sinead O’Conner
- Tweeter and the Monkey Man — The Traveling Wilburys
- Handle Me With Care — The Traveling Wilburys
- Welcome to the Terradome — Public Enemy
Pending a Listen:
The Magnificent Seven — The Clash
Marbles — Tindersticks
Raindrops — Tindersticks
Little Blue — The Beautiful South
Radio Song — The Felice Brothers
===== =====
x. Rock n Roll Singer— Mark Kozelek (AC/DC Cover).
The original Rock ’n’ Roll Singer is by AC/DC—a raw, early cut from T.N.T. (1975). It’s already got the skeleton of something great: the ambition, the defiance, the simple declaration of identity. But it’s also messy in that early AC/DC way—loose production, Bon Scott’s sardonic asides cutting across the sincerity, a kind of pub-rock sarcasm that slightly diffuses the emotional core instead of locking it in.
Kozelek hears it differently. And more importantly, he means it differently. Across multiple incarnations—solo, Red House Painters, and Sun Kil Moon—he’s returned to this song like it’s a personal doctrine. It’s not a cover so much as a repeated self-interrogation. The acoustic version strips everything down to confession; the Sun Kil Moon electric version adds weight and repetition; but it’s the live performance at The Chapel in San Francisco (Aug 19, 2017, on YouTube) that feels definitive. Electric guitar, but unpolished. Less mannered than the studio SKM version. More immediate. More exposed. And Kozelek just inhabits it.
The lyric isn’t complicated: working-class childhood, parental expectation, school, rebellion, long hair, refusal to conform. It’s the classic origin myth of rock music itself. But in Kozelek’s hands it becomes something more existential. Not just “I want to be a rock singer,” but this is the only coherent identity available to me that feels real. That chorus—repeated, rising, almost mantra-like—isn’t just aspiration. It’s fixation. He pushes it harder each time, voice tightening, almost ecstatic. There’s a strange joy in it, but also something like compulsion. This is not a person imagining a career. This is a person locking onto a destiny.
And then the darker undercurrent: the devil-in-the-blood logic of ambition. The sense that the desire itself has a cost baked into it. Kozelek doesn’t play that as metaphorical flourish; he plays it as recognition. If you want this badly enough, you don’t just chase it—you surrender something to it. That’s why it works as his thesis statement. Because Kozelek’s entire career is that tension stretched over decades. Early Red House Painters records gave him Have You Forgotten and Cruiser—songs of melodic melancholy and emotional clarity. Then the Sun Kil Moon era brings the breakthrough again with Benji (2014), an album that suddenly re-centers him in the conversation. “Ben’s My Friend” in particular catches that strange inversion of time and status—his connection to Ben Gibbard now reframed through shifting fame and distance, with that brutal line about the thin line between backstage access and feeling like an impostor in your own life.
From there, things expand—and fragment. The later Sun Kil Moon output becomes looser, more digressive: breakfast details, cats, long spoken passages, emotional drift that sometimes feels like composition and sometimes feels like overflow. The public persona starts to wobble. He writes songs like War on Drugs Can Suck My Cock after disputes over live volume at festivals. A collaboration with Jesuturns into extended monologue rather than song structure. He comments on audience demographics, once saying he used to play for “cute chicks” and now plays for “guys in tennis shoes.”
The self-mythology becomes unstable—at times self aggrandizing, at times self-undercutting, often both in the same breath. Then there are the controversies, the accusations that circulate without ever fully resolving into clean narrative closure. Combined with the relentless release schedule—multiple records a year, nearly impossible to track in full—it creates a figure who is always present and slightly out of phase with how he is being received. And yet. And yet he still lands inside my personal canon. Because at his core, Kozelek keeps returning to that original statement: I wanted to be a rock ’n’ roll singer, and I became one. Everything else—digression, controversy, excess, fatigue—is built on top of that irreducible core.
My great friend Ian (who thinks I’m nuts for still following him, despite also loving Red House Painters) isn’t alone in that reaction. Kozelek divides listeners precisely because he refuses to stabilize into a single, manageable artistic identity. But for me Singer remains clean. Not in execution, but in intent. A mantra. A declaration. A life chosen and lived, even when it gets strange. And that’s why it sits so high for me: not because it’s simple, but because it’s absolute.
x. Malibu Love Nest — Luna.
The simplest song in the top 20 and also the silkiest. First things first: Sean Eden, Luna’s long-time guitarist, is an absolute genius. His playing sits in that rare tier—alongside people like Mick Taylor or Mark Knopfler—where the instrument stops sounding like accompaniment and starts sounding like commentary. He doesn’t decorate the song; he inhabits it.
And by all accounts, Dean had to work for that role. In Dean Wareham’s memoir Black Postcards, there’s that wonderfully deadpan passage about Bryce reorganizing Sean’s process:
“Sean is a brilliant guitarist… but he is one of these people who equates the music-making process with a great deal of pain.”
That line captures something essential about Luna: the tension between ease and effort. The music feels effortless, but it absolutely isn’t. Once Eden joins the band, everything lifts. Luna becomes something more refined, more cinematic, more self-aware without losing its cool distance. Malibu Love Nest—from Rendezvous, which for my money is their best record (though Penthouse is right there)—is the clearest expression of that shift. It’s also my favorite Luna song by some distance, ahead of Chinatown, Tiger Lily, and Slash Your Tires.
On the surface, the song is almost disarmingly simple. Romantic imagery, luxury signifiers, travel, repetition of place-name refrain. A kind of dream-pop postcard written in real time. But Wareham is doing something subtler: he’s writing the fantasy while simultaneously showing you its constructedness.
The lyric moves through diamonds, bathrooms, planes, buses, trains, Italian magazines, streets, beaches—all the surfaces of a life that looks expensive and weightless from the outside. But the repetition of writing a name in all these places gives it away. This isn’t possession. It’s inscription. It’s someone trying to leave evidence inside a world that may not actually be theirs.
And that’s where Britta Phillips comes in—not just as bassist, but as tonal shift. Her presence gives the song its low-end pulse, that understated, sultry movement that turns the whole thing from detached dream into something bodily. Luna stops being just a guitar band and becomes something more fluid, more intimate, more ambiguous.
There’s also that Black Postcards anecdote about Wareham in therapy after his divorce, where he’s asked whether he’d prefer $200 or $150 per session and immediately says $150. It’s funny, but also perfectly revealing: the instinct toward practicality inside a life that otherwise drifts toward aesthetic distance. That’s Luna in miniature—romance always checked by cost, beauty always adjacent to accounting.
And then the final shift: “You will call me Robespierre…” Suddenly the dream cracks open into history, revolution, collapse, irony. The romantic fantasy is no longer just private—it’s unstable, politicized, slightly unmoored. The air changes.
That’s what makes Malibu Love Nest work. It’s not just a soft-focus love song or a beachside reverie. It’s a controlled drift between aspiration and awareness—between the life being imagined and the life quietly acknowledging it might never quite arrive. Silk on the surface. Restlessness underneath. A perfect Luna move.
x. Red River Shore — Bob Dylan.
I first heard Red River Shore the same way I heard a lot of Dylan that mattered to me—by accident, or what felt like accident at the time, buried in the sprawl of one of his Bootleg records. It didn’t announce itself. It just was, sitting there, waiting, and then suddenly it wasn’t just another outtake—it was the thing I couldn’t shake.
This is Dylan at his most haunted and most restrained. No overproduction, no grand gestures, no myth-making machinery humming in the background. Just a voice, a melody, and a memory that refuses to settle. If something like Street-Legal feels overstuffed and restless, and even the later Time Out of Mind leans into atmosphere as a kind of emotional amplifier, Red River Shore strips all of that away. It’s clean, but not simple. Bare, but not empty. The song circles around a figure—maybe a woman, maybe an idea, maybe a version of the self that no longer exists—and it never quite resolves what that figure is. That ambiguity is the whole point. Dylan doesn’t give you a stable object to hold onto; he gives you the feeling of reaching for something that keeps receding.
The “shore” itself feels less like a place and more like a threshold, somewhere between memory and myth, where the past is always just out of reach but never fully gone. And then there’s that extraordinary turn in the middle of the song, where he brings in the story of a man from long ago who could raise the dead—a clear echo of Jesus, or at least of the idea of miraculous restoration. Dylan had already passed through his overtly Christian phase by the time this surfaced, but what’s striking is how the language of that period never really leaves him. It just changes form. Here, it’s not testimony. It’s question. If that kind of power once existed—if something lost could be brought back—what does it mean that it doesn’t seem to happen anymore? That question lands hardest when he turns back inward, toward his own invisibility. There’s a line of thought that runs through the song: maybe nobody ever saw him at all, except for that one figure from the shore.
It’s devastating in its quietness. Not anger, not even sorrow exactly—just the possibility that a life can pass largely unrecognized, that meaning can hinge on a single encounter that may or may not have been real in the first place. What’s remarkable is how controlled the longing is. Dylan has written plenty of songs that ache, that burn, that lash out, but this one doesn’t do any of that. It waits. It moves at the pace of recollection, not desire. There’s a sense that whatever happened on that shore is no longer accessible in any direct way, and yet it exerts a gravitational pull on everything that comes after. The narrator isn’t trying to get back there—he knows he can’t. He’s trying to understand why it still matters.
And like the best Dylan songs, it resists interpretation even as it invites it. Is this about a lost love? A spiritual dislocation? A life not lived? Yes, and no. It holds all of those possibilities without collapsing into any one of them. It’s a song about memory as an unstable medium—how it distorts, preserves, elevates, and traps all at once. There’s a quietness to the performance that makes it feel almost private, like something not meant for a wide audience. That’s part of why it lands so hard. It doesn’t feel like a statement; it feels like a confession overheard, or maybe even a thought that slipped out before it could be edited.
Dylan has written hundreds of great songs across more phases than most artists could survive, but Red River Shore sits in a category of its own. It doesn’t rely on his persona, his legend, or even his voice at its most forceful. It relies on something deeper: his ability to inhabit uncertainty without trying to resolve it. That’s why it stays with you. Not because it explains anything, but because it refuses to.
x. Every Grain of Sand — Bob Dylan
I first heard Every Grain of Sand at 6:30 in the morning on AM radio when Bootleg Series I–III dropped in 1991, and I rushed out to buy the box set—my first ever CD purchase. The song is perfect. It summarizes Dylan’s restless, intense, questioning of his faith and suggests both belief and doubt in a truly majestic way.
To get to a song like this, Dylan had to pass through a dozen different selves. The early pure folk troubadour, the protest voice of a generation, the electric poet of love and surrealism, the mid-period wanderer—all of it accumulates here. By the time he reaches the so-called Christian era, he’s already lived several artistic lives. You can hear the turbulence of that transition in records like Street-Legal, with its overproduction and relative lyrical sprawl, before the much cleaner, more direct Slow Train Coming sharpens the message into something more doctrinal, more certain. And yet Every Grain of Sand doesn’t sound certain at all. That’s what makes it extraordinary.
Even coming out of a period of apparent conversion—shaped, at least in part, by the orbit of his gospel-era collaborators and the intensity of that moment—it refuses to settle into simple testimony. It doesn’t preach. It wavers. It searches. The voice in the song is not anchored; it’s oscillating, moving between conviction and isolation, presence and absence.That tension is everything. Dylan is not resolving faith here—he’s inhabiting it, in all its instability. The sense that there might be something there, and the equally powerful sense that there might not be, coexist without canceling each other out. The song holds both, and in doing so, it becomes larger than any one phase or identity he’s ever occupied. Unbelievable.
The bootleg version—with the faint, accidental intrusion of a barking dog in the background—is far prettier and more soulful than the also great album version. It feels less finished, more human, more exposed—closer to whatever fragile truth the song is reaching toward. It’s x on the list, but one in my soul.
x. Easy / Lucky / Free — Bright Eyes.
I love Bright Eyes, but I love Conor Oberst solo even more—Cape Canaveral sits higher for me—but Easy / Lucky / Freeis a killer. It’s one of those songs that feels light on the surface—almost buoyant—but carries a depth that sneaks up on you. That’s a rare trick, and Oberst pulls it off without seeming to try. The song moves with an ease that belies how much is actually going on underneath. There’s reflection, acceptance, a kind of cautious optimism that never tips into naïveté. It feels like someone taking stock of a life that’s been messy, uncertain, sometimes self-destructive, and deciding—quietly—that it’s still worth something. Not in a grand, declarative way, but in a lived-in, almost offhand recognition.
Part of what makes the song endure is how open it is. It doesn’t force a meaning; it leaves space for you to step into it. That’s something Oberst has gotten better and better at over time. The earlier Bright Eyes records—I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning, for instance—are incredible, but they’re more immediate, more raw in their expression. By the time you get to Digital Ash in a Digital Urn, which I think is the best Bright Eyes record, the songwriting has deepened. There’s more control, more subtlety, more willingness to let a song breathe. Easy / Lucky / Free sits right in that evolution. It’s not trying to overwhelm you; it’s trying to stay with you. And it does There’s also a great conversation around the song in its afterlife.
The Dawes cover is marvelous—faithful but expanded, bringing a different kind of warmth and clarity to it. And then there’s the reciprocal moment: Oberst covering Million Dollar Bill, Dawes’ best song, on their collaboration. It’s a perfect exchange—two artists who clearly hear each other, trading songs and making them their own. Oberst is my number five artist of all time, and it’s songs like this that make that ranking feel inevitable. The songwriting has only gotten deeper with time, more assured without losing that early vulnerability. And even though Cape might sit higher, Easy / Lucky / Free is right there, doing something just as difficult in a completely different register. So, so good.
x. Double — Michael Knott
This song sits as part of a remarkable one-two punch in Knott’s catalog—Double at 14 and Rocket at 15. Rocket is the better-known, more frequently covered song, the one that tends to travel. But Double might actually be the deeper cut, the one that does more with less and lingers longer once it’s over. On its face, the song is almost disarmingly simple: a guy at a bar knocks over another guy’s drink at the pool table, offers to replace it, and the other guy asks for a double instead. The narrator digs out four bucks—his last—and buys it.
That’s the whole setup. It’s small, almost nothing. A minor act of compensation in a place where those transactions happen all the time. But Knott is never just writing the surface story. What unfolds underneath is something much heavier, something that shifts the song from anecdote to diagnosis. The bar becomes a threshold space—where the choices you make, even small ones, echo into the life waiting for you at home. The song moves forward and suddenly you’re not at the pool table anymore; you’re waking up in a house with responsibilities you can barely face. A child needs you. Your partner is trying to hold things together. There’s church, obligation, the faint outline of a life that’s supposed to be stable and meaningful, and the overwhelming sense that you are not meeting it.
And then Knott does something devastating: he reframes the entire situation through another failing marriage—the preacher, the supposed moral center, the guiding light for years, whose own life is unraveling. The implication lands hard and quietly: if even that doesn’t hold, what chance does anything else have? The song becomes about marriage—not in the sentimental or idealized sense, but in the lived reality of it. Fatigue, compromise, small resentments, moments of grace that don’t quite offset the weight of everything else. The double at the bar starts to feel like more than a drink—it’s a decision, a coping mechanism, a tiny tilt in a direction that’s already dangerous.
Knott’s work has always carried that edge of autobiography, that sense that he’s not writing about struggle so much as from within it. His battles with alcohol were real, long-standing, and central to both his life and his art—something he never fully resolved, only wrestled with in public through his songs. But while that struggle shaped him, it is not officially cited as the cause of his death, which remains undisclosed. What makes Double so powerful is how much it trusts the listener. It doesn’t explain itself. It doesn’t moralize. It presents a series of moments—bar, home, church—and lets you connect them, lets you feel the throughline without being told what it is. And once you see it, you can’t unsee it. That’s why it might be Knott’s best song, even if Rocket gets the attention. Double doesn’t announce itself. It just sits there, quietly devastating, doing its work long after the song is over.
x. Thrasher — Neil Young.
There are so many great Neil Young songs that could go up here—On the Beach, Roll Another Number for the Road, Albuquerque, Cortez the Killer, Powderfinger. But it’s Thrasher that makes the list. This is a highly allusive, poetic, and suggestive song—TV, the Grand Canyon, diamonds—but it really feels like it’s about the aftermath of the 60s: its disillusionment, its lost promise, the slow realization that whatever was supposed to change didn’t quite change the way anyone thought it would. The idealism curdles, or maybe just hardens. What once felt fluid starts to set.
“They were lost in rock formations / they became park bench formations”—to me, that still reads as a shot across the bow at Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. Young keeps moving, keeps shedding skins, while the others settle, calcify, become part of the landscape they once tried to reshape. But the line opens up beyond that. “Rock formations” suggests something vast, natural, even awe-inspiring—people absorbed into something larger than themselves. “Park bench formations” is smaller, static, almost resigned—people sitting still, watching instead of acting, becoming fixtures rather than forces. That shift—from movement to stasis, from formation to being formed—feels like the real subject of the song. Not just what happened to CSNY, but what happened to a whole generation that thought it was going to keep moving forever. And then there’s the title.
What the hell is a “Thrasher,” anyway? I mean a thresher is a machine that separates grain from chaff. Something that strips away the unnecessary to get at what’s essential. But a Thrasher? In any case, the song has that quality—it cuts, it reduces, it leaves you with something bare and slightly unsettling. It’s not nostalgic. It’s diagnostic. Young only played it live once, flubbed some lines, and never went back to it. That almost adds to the mystique. It feels like a song that wasn’t meant to be repeated too often, like it captured something too specific, too transitional, to comfortably revisit. The song is delivered in Young’s patented high-pitched voice, with a finely tuned acoustic guitar that gives it a kind of fragile clarity.
It’s a beautiful song and my favorite on a long, long list of great ones.
x. April the 14th Part II— Gillian Welch
I first heard April the 14th, Part II the way a lot of the best music enters your life—over the radio, half by accident, but not really. Conor Oberst had cited it as one of his favorites, and that was enough to lean in, but the song itself did the rest. It didn’t ask for attention; it quietly demanded it. Welch’s partnership with David Rawlings is one of the great creative pairings in American music—two artists so attuned to each other that the line between writer and interpreter almost disappears. Across an extraordinary catalog, they’ve built a sound that feels both ancient and immediate, rooted in tradition but never derivative. April the 14th, Part II sits right at the center of that achievement.
The song takes its title—and its loose conceptual grounding—from the date of Abraham Lincoln’s assassination, but it doesn’t approach history in a straightforward way. Instead, it fractures it, reframes it, turns it into something lived-in and contemporary. The past isn’t something to be preserved behind glass; it’s something that leaks into the present, reshaping it in ways that aren’t always obvious. Lincoln is there, but so are highways, bars, long drives, and the peculiar loneliness of being in motion for too long. That’s where Welch’s genius shows most clearly. She understands the continuity between those worlds—the mythic American past and the far less romantic present of touring musicians, late nights, and empty miles. When she drops a line about a girl passed out in the backseat, it doesn’t feel like an aside. It feels like evidence. She knows the road—not the idea of it, not the mythology, but the actual, grinding, disorienting reality of it. The song carries that knowledge without ever turning didactic.
There’s also something deeply American in how she holds all of this together. Not patriotic, not sentimental, but recognizably American in its contradictions—history and amnesia, ambition and exhaustion, beauty and wreckage. In that sense, she stands in a clear lineage with artists like Townes Van Zandt and Emmylou Harris, inheriting their sense of narrative, their attention to emotional truth, and their ability to let a song breathe without forcing it toward resolution. And yet she never feels like an imitator. The voice, the phrasing, the perspective—it’s all distinctly her own. A true American original. April the 14th, Part II doesn’t resolve its tensions. It lets them sit. History and the present, myth and reality, movement and stasis—they all coexist without collapsing into something neat. That’s what gives the song its weight. It’s not trying to tell you what America is. It’s showing you what it feels like to live inside it. And once you hear it, you don’t forget it.
The Kyoto Kibbitzer 